Tracks
| # | Title | Sung by | |
|---|---|---|---|
| A1 | Overture / Rock Island | Orchestra / Paul Reed & Traveling Salesmen | |
| A2 | Iowa Stubborn | Ensemble | |
| A3 | Trouble | Robert Preston & Ensemble | |
| A4 | Piano Lesson | Barbara Cook & Pert Kelton | |
| A5 | Goodnight My Someone | Barbara Cook | |
| A6 | Seventy Six Trombones | Robert Preston & Ensemble | |
| A7 | Sincere | The Buffalo Bills | |
| A8 | The Sadder‐But‐Wiser Girl | Robert Preston | |
| A9 | Pickalittle / Goodnight Ladies | Misses Raymond, Swann, Mondo, Rice, Flynn & The Buffalo Bills | |
| B1 | Marian the Librarian | Robert Preston | |
| B2 | My White Knight | Barbara Cook | |
| B3 | Wells Fargo Wagon | Eddie Hodges & Ensemble | |
| B4 | It’s You | The Buffalo Bills | |
| B5 | Shipoopi | Iggie Wolfington & Ensemble | |
| B6 | Lida Rose / Will I Ever Tell You | Meredith Willson & The Buffalo Bills | |
| B7 | Gary, Indiana | Eddie Hodges | |
| B8 | Till There Was You | Barbara Cook & Robert Preston | |
| B9 | Finale | Entire Company |
Member reviews
Source: MusicBrainz release group 221b3ed3-1349-3e72-8da4-d412e2df0a7e (CC0). Cover: Cover Art Archive.