Tracks
| # | Title | Sung by | |
|---|---|---|---|
| A1 | What's So Good About It (You're My Baby) | Jerry Butler | 4:54 |
| A2 | If I Could Remember (Not Ever Having You) | Jerry Butler | 6:25 |
| A3 | I Only Have Eyes for You | Jerry Butler | 3:31 |
| A4 | That's the Way It Was (That's the Way It Is) | Jerry Butler | 4:59 |
| B1 | One Night Affair | Jerry Butler | 3:25 |
| B2 | A Prayer | Jerry Butler | 3:24 |
| B3 | Get on the Case | Jerry Butler | 5:21 |
| B4 | So Far Away | Jerry Butler | 5:06 |
| C1 | I Need You | Jerry Butler | 5:55 |
| C2 | You Can't Always Tell | Jerry Butler feat. Brenda Lee Eager | 5:47 |
| C3 | Stop Steppin' on My Dreams | Jerry Butler | 3:52 |
| C4 | Baby I'm a Want You | Jerry Butler | 3:20 |
| D1 | (They Long to Be) Close to You | Jerry Butler feat. Brenda Lee Eager | 4:13 |
| D2 | Don't Rip Me Off | Jerry Butler | 4:01 |
| D3 | The Masquerade is Over / Since I Fell for You | Jerry Butler | 6:10 |
| D4 | All Kinds of People | Jerry Butler | 4:53 |
Source: MusicBrainz release group a450b9a3-5f11-4bd6-8905-73f6c5d1a879 (CC0). Cover: Cover Art Archive.