Tracks
| # | Title | Sung by | |
|---|---|---|---|
| A1 | Twelve Days of Christmas | John Denver & The Muppets | 4:24 |
| A2 | Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas | John Denver & The Muppets | 1:51 |
| A3 | The Peace Carol | John Denver & The Muppets | 2:47 |
| A4 | Christmas Is Coming | John Denver & The Muppets | 1:15 |
| A5 | A Baby Just Like You | John Denver & The Muppets | 2:54 |
| A6 | Deck the Halls | John Denver & The Muppets | 1:37 |
| A7 | When the River Meets the Sea | John Denver & The Muppets | 2:44 |
| B1 | Little Saint Nick | John Denver & The Muppets | 2:24 |
| B2 | Noel: Christmas Eve, 1913 | John Denver & The Muppets | 2:54 |
| B3 | The Christmas Wish | John Denver & The Muppets | 3:29 |
| B4 | Medley: Alfie the Christmas Tree / Carol for a Christmas Tree / It's in Every One of Us | John Denver & The Muppets | 4:37 |
| B5 | Silent Night, Holy Night | John Denver & The Muppets | 3:11 |
| B6 | We Wish You a Merry Christmas | John Denver & The Muppets | 1:05 |
Member reviews
Source: MusicBrainz release group 4523c83b-1a17-48fe-adc3-f2e6dd8dab94 (CC0). Cover: Cover Art Archive.