Tracks
| # | Title | Sung by | |
|---|
| 1 | Gather ’Round, Ye Children, Come | Andrew Peterson, Eric Peters, Matthew Perryman Jones, Pappy Peters | 3:18 |
| 2 | Passover Us | Andrew Peterson, Randall Goodgame, Sandra McCracken, Jimmy Hoyt-Washington, Anklejelly Jones | 4:33 |
| 3 | So Long, Moses | Andrew Peterson, Andrew Osenga, Jeremy Casella, Shane Williams | 6:12 |
| 4 | Deliver Us | Andrew Peterson, Derek Webb, Andrew Osenga | 3:49 |
| 5 | O Come, O Come, Emmanuel | Andrew Peterson | 2:31 |
| 6 | Matthew’s Begats | Andrew Peterson | 2:17 |
| 7 | It Came to Pass | Andrew Peterson, Jill Phillips | 2:50 |
| 8 | Labor of Love | Andrew Peterson, Jill Phillips | 4:32 |
| 9 | The Holly and the Ivy | Andrew Peterson | 1:54 |
| 10 | While Shepherds Watched Their Flocks | Andrew Peterson, Derek Webb, Eric Peters, Sandra McCracken, Andrew Osenga, Jeremy Casella, Jonathan Noel, Danielle Peters, Alison Osenga, Amanda Noel | 3:23 |
| 11 | Behold the Lamb of God | Andrew Peterson, Amanda Noel, Fernando Orgega | 4:02 |
| 12 | The Theme of My Song (reprise) | Andrew Peterson, Derek Webb, Jill Phillips, Sandra McCracken, Andrew Osenga, Jonathan Noel, Shane Williams, Alison Osenga, Amanda Noel | 4:21 |
Source: MusicBrainz release group 64ccda35-b3be-3739-816c-e19ebcdcd913 (CC0). Cover: Cover Art Archive.