Tracks
| # | Title | Sung by | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | You'd Be Surprised | Mike Birbiglia | 3:13 |
| 2 | Cracka | Mike Birbiglia | 1:51 |
| 3 | Whiffle Ball Tony | Mike Birbiglia | 3:27 |
| 4 | Sympathy Card | Mike Birbiglia | 1:04 |
| 5 | Hip Hop Animosity | Mike Birbiglia | 5:57 |
| 6 | Two Drink Mike | Mike Birbiglia | 6:03 |
| 7 | Sex, Tennis, and Pandas | Mike Birbiglia | 5:50 |
| 8 | I'm Crazy and Gay Cats | Mike Birbiglia | 7:17 |
| 9 | Whatever You Are, Be a Good One | Mike Birbiglia | 4:18 |
| 10 | Arctic Fox It's a Setup! | Mike Birbiglia | 5:23 |
| 11 | No, but I Heard About It | Mike Birbiglia | 1:07 |
| 12 | Dammit I'm Eatin' Pretzels | Mike Birbiglia | 3:10 |
| 13 | The Oatmeal Song | Mike Birbiglia | 3:26 |
| 14 | The Guitar Guy at the Party | Mike Birbiglia | 3:26 |
| 15 | Thanks for Coming Song | Mike Birbiglia | 2:05 |
| 16 | The Guitar Guy at the Party (radio version) | Mike Birbiglia | 3:05 |
Source: MusicBrainz release group 90251157-f3e1-31f0-804a-16a59cf143b5 (CC0). Cover: Cover Art Archive.