Tracks
| # | Title | Sung by | |
|---|---|---|---|
| A1 | Oh What a Night | The Dells | 2:50 |
| A2 | For Your Precious Love | Jerry Butler | 2:41 |
| A3 | I'll Be Home | The Flamingos | 3:03 |
| A4 | Sixteen Candles | The Crests | 2:51 |
| A5 | Crying in the Chapel | Sonny Til & The Orioles | 3:07 |
| A6 | Why Don't You Write Me | The Jacks | 2:48 |
| A7 | In the Still of the Night | Fred Parris, Al Denby, Ed Martin, Jim Freeman, Nat Mosley | 3:04 |
| B1 | Sincerely | Harvey Fuqua, Bobby Lester, Pete Graves, Prentiss Barnes | 3:09 |
| B2 | Eddie My Love | The Teen Queens | 2:45 |
| B3 | Silhouettes | The Rays | 2:46 |
| B4 | Tears on My Pillow | Little Anthony & the Imperials | 2:17 |
| B5 | We Belong Together | Robert and Johnny | 2:48 |
| B6 | Tonight Tonight | The Mello-Kings | 2:30 |
| B7 | Goodnight My Love | Jesse Belvin | 3:05 |
Source: MusicBrainz release group 8bb07ea4-d3c0-3b0a-a1c6-af8ca0b274d3 (CC0). Cover: Cover Art Archive.