Skip to content
CharmySongs
Sign inRegister
Song

I'm Not That Girl

I'm Not That Girl (reprise)
First released 2003Pop15 recordingson 61 releases
Listen onSpotify ↗Apple Music ↗Tidal ↗

Written by

Stephen SchwartzComposerStephen SchwartzLyricist

From the films

Wicked: For GoodWicked: For Good2025the film on Charmy Movies ↗
WickedWicked2024the film on Charmy Movies ↗
Wicked: One Wonderful NightWicked: One Wonderful Night2025the film on Charmy Movies ↗
Wicked2004the film on Charmy Movies ↗

Recordings

PerformanceBy
I'm Not That GirlStephen Schwartz3:00
I'm Not That GirlStephen Schwartz3:00
I’m Not That GirlKerry Ellis3:49
I’m Not That GirlIdina Menzel3:02
I’m Not That Girl (reprise)Kristin Chenoweth0:50
I'm Not That GirlKerry Ellis & Brian May3:26
I’m Not That Girl (live)Idina Menzel3:19
I´m Not That GirlBrian May & Kerry Ellis3:26
I’m Not That GirlIdina Menzel2:59
I’m Not That GirlCynthia Erivo3:57
I’m Not That Girl (sing-along)Wicked Movie Cast & The Wicked Orchestra3:56
I’m Not That Girl (reprise)Ariana Grande2:11
I’m Not That GirlCynthia Erivo3:58
I’m Not That GirlCynthia Erivo3:58
Not That GirlJonathan Young, Brandon McInnis & Caleb Hyles3:42

On these albums

Wicked
WickedStephen Schwartz · 2003Soundtrack
Piano Tribute to Wicked
Piano Tribute to WickedStephen Schwartz · 2006
Wicked in Rock
Wicked in RockKerry Ellis · 2008
Anthems
AnthemsKerry Ellis · 2010
Acoustic by Candlelight: Live on the Born Free Tour
Acoustic by Candlelight: Live on the Born Free TourKerry Ellis & Brian May · 2013
The Candlelight Concerts: Live at Montreux 2013
The Candlelight Concerts: Live at Montreux 2013Brian May & Kerry Ellis · 2013
idina: live
idina: liveIdina Menzel · 2018
Wicked: The Soundtrack
Wicked: The SoundtrackStephen Schwartz · 2024Soundtrack
Wicked: The Soundtrack (sing-along)
Wicked: The Soundtrack (sing-along)Stephen Schwartz · 2024Soundtrack
Wicked: For Good – The Soundtrack
Wicked: For Good – The SoundtrackStephen Schwartz · 2025Soundtrack
Wicked: One Wonderful Night
Wicked: One Wonderful NightStephen Schwartz · 2025Soundtrack
Wicked Meets Metal
Wicked Meets MetalJonathan Young · 2026
Wicked: The Complete Soundtrack
Wicked: The Complete SoundtrackStephen Schwartz · 2026Soundtrack
Defying Gravity (Extended Male Version)
Defying Gravity (Extended Male Version)Jonathan Young, Brandon McInnis, Caleb Hyles · 2026

Source: MusicBrainz work 25be2832-2a15-4a21-80e6-09384a56fc79 (CC0).