Skip to content
CharmySongs
Sign inRegister
Song

6 Romances, op. 6, no. 5: Why? (Отчего?)

6 Romances, op. 6 no. 5: Why?
First released 1982Russian13 recordingson 21 releases

Written by

Пётр Ильич ЧайковскийComposerHeinrich HeineLyricistЛев МейTranslator

Recordings

PerformanceBy
Otchevo?, op. 6 no. 5Elisabeth Söderström, Roger Vignoles3:01
Why?Olga Borodina, Larissa Gergieva2:58
Why? op. 6 no. 5Christianne Stotijn, Julius Drake2:56
Pourquoi ?Enrico Caruso, Victor Orchestra, Josef Pasternack3:06
Why?, op. 6 no. 5Любовь Казарновская, Ljuba Orfenova3:44
Why?Anastasia Markina, Eugene Osadchy2:42
Romances, op. 6: No. 5. Why? ModeratoLisa Batiashvili, Yannick Nézet-Séguin2:24
Why?Daniil Shtoda, Larissa Gergieva2:45
Why, op. 6, no. 5Takako Nishizaki, Queensland Symphony Orchestra, Peter Breiner2:56
Warum, op. 6 no. 5Nadia Krasteva, Dora Deliyska3:10
6 Romances, op. 6: V. Otchevo?Elisabeth Söderström, Vladimir Ashkenazy3:26
Russian Songs & Opera Arias: "Why?" op. 6, no. 5Galina Vishnevskaya, Mstislav Rostropovich4:09
6 Romances, Op. 6, TH 93: No. 5, Why?Piotr Beczała, Helmut Deutsch2:49

On these albums

Tchaikovsky: Songs, Vol. 1
Tchaikovsky: Songs, Vol. 1Tchaikovsky; Elisabeth Söderström & Vladimir Ashkenazy · 1982
The Caruso Edition, Volume IV: 1916–1921
The Caruso Edition, Volume IV: 1916–1921Enrico Caruso · 1991
“None but the lonely heart”: Tchaikovsky Romances
“None but the lonely heart”: Tchaikovsky RomancesTchaikovsky; Olga Borodina, Larissa Gergieva · 1994
Liszt / Schubert / Tchaikovsky / Rachmaninov / Grieg / Strauss
Liszt / Schubert / Tchaikovsky / Rachmaninov / Grieg / StraussLiszt, Schubert, Tchaikovsky, Rachmaninov, Grieg, Strauss; Elisabeth Söderström, Martin Isepp, Roger Vignoles · 2001
None but the Lonely Heart
None but the Lonely HeartTchaikovsky: Takako Nishizaki, Queensland Symphony Orchestra, Peter Breiner · 2001
Complete Songs, Vol. 3
Complete Songs, Vol. 3Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky; Ljuba Kazarnovskaya, Ljuba Orfenova · 2001
Great Recordings of the Century New Releases Summer / Autumn 2003
Great Recordings of the Century New Releases Summer / Autumn 2003Various Artists · 2003
The Complete Recordings, Volume 10
The Complete Recordings, Volume 10Enrico Caruso · 2003
The Complete Recordings: Recorded 1902-1920
The Complete Recordings: Recorded 1902-1920Enrico Caruso · 2004
Romances
RomancesTchaikovsky; Christianne Stotijn, Julius Drake · 2009
Russian Romances: Joys and Sorrows
Russian Romances: Joys and SorrowsEugene Osadchy, Anastasia Markina · 2010
Tchaikovsky Edition
Tchaikovsky EditionPyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky · 2011
Pathétique
PathétiqueTchaikovsky; Yannick Nézet-Séguin, Lisa Batiashvili, Rotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra · 2013
Tchaikovsky Masterworks Edition
Tchaikovsky Masterworks EditionПётр Ильич Чайковский · 2015
None but the Lonely Heart
None but the Lonely HeartPyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky; Nadia Krasteva, Dora Deliyska · 2016
The Solo & Chamber Recordings
The Solo & Chamber RecordingsVladimir Ashkenazy · 2017
Complete Chamber Music & Lieder Recordings
Complete Chamber Music & Lieder RecordingsVladimir Ashkenazy · 2023
Romances
RomancesСергей Рахманинов, Пётр Ильич Чайковский; Piotr Beczała, Helmut Deutsch · 2023
Songs
SongsBalakirev, Rimsky-Korsakov, Cui, Tchaikovsky, Rachmaninov; Daniil Shtoda, Larissa Gergieva
Songs by Tchaikovsky and Britten
Songs by Tchaikovsky and BrittenTchaikovsky, Benjamin Britten; Galina Vishnevskaya, Mstislav Rostropovich

Source: MusicBrainz work c091e7ae-c690-304b-9d53-11934a5fa260 (CC0).