When My Sugar Walks Down the Street

On these albums

I’ll Buy You a StarJohnny Mathis with Nelson Riddle and His Orchestra · 1961

I’ll Buy You a Star / Live It Up!Johnny Mathis · 2009

The Voice of Romance: The Columbia Original Album CollectionJohnny Mathis · 2017

Source: MusicBrainz recording ada1bdfb-06e3-410b-8ecb-a3d433f2d125 (CC0).