On these albums
Killing Me Softly With Her SongJohnny Mathis · 1973
The Mathis Collection: 40 of My Favourite SongsJohnny Mathis · 1977
Tears and LaughterJohnny Mathis · 1980
Love SongsJohnny Mathis · 2003
Las 66 Favoritas de Iñigo y Pardo Vol.8 Y No Es Un Día CualquieraVarious Artists · 2014
The Voice of Romance: The Columbia Original Album CollectionJohnny Mathis · 2017
Killing Me Softly With Her Song / When Will I See You AgainJohnny Mathis · 2019
Me & Mrs Jones / Killing Me Softly With Her Song / I'm Coming Home / FeelingsJohnny Mathis · 2022
Source: MusicBrainz recording 984cc7f9-cf7e-4067-905d-5845e506bcf3 (CC0).